Ken Paxton Jobs Texas

Ken Paxton Spent Nearly Four Years Suing to Take Pregnancy Protections Away From Texas State Workers. A 9-8 Court Just Gave Him the Win.

The full Fifth Circuit ruled 9-8 that the federal government can't enforce the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the state of Texas. Out of a $1.7 trillion bill, Paxton went after that law and one small immigration program, and Texas kept the bill's money.

Ken Paxton Spent Nearly Four Years Suing to Take Pregnancy Protections Away From Texas State Workers. A 9-8 Court Just Gave Him the Win.
Photo: Patrick Semansky / AP, via The Washington Sun

On Friday, November 20, the full federal appeals court for Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi ruled 9 to 8 that the federal government can't enforce the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the state of Texas.

That is the law that makes employers give pregnant workers reasonable help on the job, like time off for medical appointments and a break from heavy lifting. The ruling means the state of Texas, as an employer, doesn't have to answer to it.

The case was brought by Ken Paxton. And of all the lawsuits the outgoing attorney general has filed, it is one he never let go.

What Paxton was after

In February 2023, Paxton sued the Biden administration over the giant $1.7 trillion government funding bill Congress passed in December 2022. His argument was about how it passed. During COVID, the House let members vote by proxy, meaning a colleague in the room cast their vote for them. Paxton said those absent members couldn't count toward the number of members needed to do business, so the bill never legally passed.

His office's announcement said the bill "was never lawfully enacted, is unconstitutional, and the federal government should be enjoined from implementing it." Paxton himself blamed "former Speaker Nancy Pelosi" for using proxy voting "to upend our constitutional system."

But in court, Paxton didn't ask to throw out the whole bill. According to the court's opinion, Texas asked to block just two pieces of it as they applied to Texas: the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, and a $20 million immigration program. (The lower court ruled Texas had no standing to challenge the immigration program, so the case came down to the pregnancy law.)

Paxton's lawsuit said the pregnancy law put an undue burden on the state government to accommodate its pregnant employees, the Texas Tribune reported.

That's the whole case. Out of a $1.7 trillion bill, the part Paxton ended up fighting over was the part that protects pregnant women at work.

What the law does

The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act came after a decades-long campaign by women's groups, the Associated Press reported, highlighting pregnant workers, especially in low-wage jobs, who were routinely forced off the job after asking for help.

The law stops employers from denying pregnant workers job opportunities, or forcing them onto leave, when a simple change would let them keep working, the Texas Tribune reported. It also lets workers sue when an employer refuses.

A federal judge in Lubbock first sided with Paxton in February 2024 and blocked the law for the Texas state government and its agencies. A three-judge panel of the appeals court reversed that in August 2025, finding the law was passed properly. Paxton kept going. The full court reheard the case, and on November 20 the nine-judge majority agreed with him.

"While retaining millions in federal funding"

Eight judges dissented. Judge James Graves, writing for seven of them, opened with one sentence that sums up the case. Texas, he wrote, was "attempting to veto Congress's protections for pregnant workers and new parents while retaining millions in federal funding."

He came back to it at the end. The same bill pays for health, mental health and education benefits for veterans, he noted, and the court's ruling leaves all of that alone. "Nor does the majority explain how Texas may seek to enjoin enforcement of the PWFA despite accepting millions of dollars under the very same Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023," Graves wrote.

In other words: if the bill was illegal, it was illegal for the money Texas took, too. The court only applied it to the pregnant workers.

Proxy voting was a bipartisan habit

Paxton pinned proxy voting on Pelosi. But members of both parties used proxy votes for all kinds of reasons, from meeting with lobbyists to promoting books, the Texas Tribune reported.

That includes the Republicans who sued to end it. Greg Steube sued to stop proxy voting, promised in writing never to use it, and then used it to go speak at CPAC.

The fight also split Republicans. Paxton's case drew opposition from Republicans, including former Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, who defended the proxy rule, the AP reported. Even Trump's Justice Department kept fighting the lawsuit in 2025.

The AP also noted that if Paxton won, it could help open the door to court challenges against other laws passed by proxy during the pandemic. Now he has won, before the full appeals court that covers Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.

The one he didn't drop

Paxton lost his race for the U.S. Senate on November 3. Within two weeks, his office quietly dropped its cases against a migrant shelter, an immigrant rights group, Texas Muslims and the NCAA.

He didn't drop this one. It was a nearly four-year effort to get out from under a federal law that protects pregnant women who work for the state.

It's a pattern. Paxton's Texas also stayed in a lawsuit until a judge erased a rule protecting disabled people's care at home. And it is happening as Trump's own EEOC has reportedly been planning to narrow the rules behind this same law.

What the ruling shows

Ken Paxton sued in 2023 to stop the federal government from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the state of Texas, arguing the law put an undue burden on the state to accommodate its pregnant employees. Out of a $1.7 trillion bill, Texas asked to block only that law and one $20 million immigration program, and kept the rest of the bill's money. On November 20, after losing at the three-judge panel in 2025, Paxton won 9 to 8 before the full appeals court, and pregnant Texas state workers lost the right to have the federal government enforce that law on their behalf.

Sources

Take Action →
Ken Paxton Report Card