Sarah Sanders Voting RightsChecks & Balances Arkansas

Sarah Sanders Is Filling One Empty Senate Seat in 91 Days. The One Held by a Foe of Her Prison, She Tried to Leave Empty for 427.

Arkansas law says a vacant legislative seat gets a special election within 150 days. Sanders set Gary Stubblefield's for 427 days out — leaving the Franklin County district fighting her prison with no senator — until a Franklin County man sued and the courts made her follow the law.

Sarah Sanders Is Filling One Empty Senate Seat in 91 Days. The One Held by a Foe of Her Prison, She Tried to Leave Empty for 427.
Photo: KATV

When an Arkansas state senator leaves office, the law gives the governor a deadline. A special election to fill the seat has to be held within 150 days, unless that's "impracticable or unduly burdensome."

Sarah Sanders can meet that deadline. She just did.

When state Sen. Jonathan Dismang resigned on September 15 of this year, Sanders scheduled the special election within three days. When only four candidates filed and no primary was needed, state law required her to move it up, and she did — to December 15. The people of Senate District 18 will have a new senator when the Legislature opens on January 11 — 91 days, start to finish.

That's how former state Senate Minority Leader Keith Ingram lays it out in a column in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette. Then he describes the other vacancy.

The seat she left empty

Sen. Gary Stubblefield, R-Branch, died on September 2, 2025. His district, Senate District 26, covers parts of Franklin, Johnson, Logan and Sebastian counties.

It also includes Franklin County, where Sanders wanted to build her 3,000-bed prison. Stubblefield was one of its most vocal opponents. The money for her prison failed five times during the 2025 legislative session.

According to Ingram, Sanders first set the special election for November 3, 2026 — 427 days after the seat went empty, and 277 days past the legal deadline. After objections from both parties, she moved it to June 9, 2026. In her election call, she declared it "impracticable or unduly burdensome" to hold an election within 150 days.

Either date meant the district would have no senator at the 2026 fiscal session, when the Legislature decides the state's budget.

She never explained why it was too hard to hold an election on time in District 26, but not in District 18.

A Franklin County man had to sue her

It took a Franklin County resident, Colt Shelby — who went on to run against her as the Libertarian nominee for governor — to make the governor follow the law.

Shelby sued on October 6, 2025, naming Sanders and the secretary of state. His lawyer pointed out that when a Springdale senator resigned in 2021, Gov. Asa Hutchinson set a schedule that worked — and that election officials had testified they could do the same here.

On October 22, Circuit Judge Patricia James ruled for Shelby. Sanders, defended by Attorney General Tim Griffin, asked the Arkansas Supreme Court to put the ruling on hold. The court refused. Only then did Sanders move the election to March 3, 2026.

"A matter of representation for the people," Shelby told KATV. "With us going into session without representation on the, one of the biggest things that Franklin County has ever seen, it's, it's insanity to even allow that to be possible."

It wasn't the only seat. Sanders also set a late special election for House District 70 in Pulaski County — a North Little Rock and Sherwood seat KATV describes as "poised to swing Democrat." The Democratic Party of Arkansas sued over that one, and won too. And it did swing Democratic.

Sanders kept fighting both rulings for months. In May 2026, the Arkansas Supreme Court dismissed her appeals, ending what KATV called "a legal battle that began last October after the governor set special elections for a vacant Senate and House seat hundreds of days past a statutory deadline."

She was the outlier

Ingram, who served in the state Senate from 2013 to 2023, looked at how other governors have handled this.

Since 2011, he writes, governors of both parties have called 17 special legislative elections. Eight were held within the 150-day window. The others ran late by an average of less than 26 days. Asa Hutchinson and Mike Beebe each managed to fill a Senate seat in time for a fiscal session.

The Stubblefield seat was the one outlier — and the only special election in that span where a governor had to change the date she first announced.

Ingram says he suspects the reason was the prison, and admits he could be wrong. But the pattern is plain: the two seats Sanders tried to leave empty through the fiscal session were a district fighting her prison and a district about to elect a Democrat.

This fits how she treats the people who stood in the way of that prison. After Republican senators killed it, Sanders recruited primary challengers against the ones who stopped her — and went 0 for 3.

The bottom line

Arkansas law gives the governor 150 days to fill a vacant legislative seat. Sarah Sanders scheduled Jonathan Dismang's Senate seat to be filled in 91 days, but set the election for Gary Stubblefield's seat — in the Franklin County district fighting her prison — 427 days out, then 280, until a Franklin County man sued and the courts forced her to move it to March. She also tried to leave a Democratic-leaning House seat empty, lost that lawsuit too, and fought both rulings until the Arkansas Supreme Court threw out her appeals.

Source

Sarah Sanders and the tale of two legislative vacancies — Keith M. Ingram, Arkansas Democrat-Gazette

Take Action →
Sarah Sanders Report Card